Iconic Mackinac Island West Bluff Location with Private Carriage House

Perched along the coveted West Bluff, with sweeping sunset views across the Straits of Mackinac and direct sightlines to the iconic Grand Hotel, this extraordinary Victorian cottage captures the very essence of Mackinac Island living.

Originally built in 1889 by Charles Caskey, the residence stands as a beautiful reflection of the Island’s storied past. In 2013, it underwent a comprehensive transformation, thoughtfully expanded and rebuilt to preserve its historic character while delivering modern comfort and performance. The result is a rare offering on the Bluff: timeless architecture paired with true turnkey condition.

The main cottage now spans approximately 4,025 square feet and offers five bedrooms, four full baths, and one half baths. A gracious 1,475 square foot addition introduced a generous primary suite and enhanced the home’s flow, creating inviting spaces for gathering while maintaining the intimacy and charm of a classic Mackinac cottage.

Large windows frame panoramic water views and bathe the interiors in natural light. The expansive front porch is made for summer evenings, sunset cocktails, and the quiet rhythm of carriage horses passing by. Inside, the updated kitchen and living areas blend seamlessly, ideal for entertaining family and friends. Mechanical systems, roof, foundation, electrical, plumbing, and exterior finishes were all replaced or upgraded during the renovation, offering the comfort of modern infrastructure within a historic shell.

Adding to the estate is a separate 2,006 square foot carriage house built in 2004. The upper level includes a two bedroom, one bath apartment with living room and kitchen, perfect for guests, caretakers, or extended family. Below, the structure is fully outfitted for equestrian use with two stalls, tack room, laundry, hay loft with storage for approximately 350 bales, and ample space for multiple carriages. A fenced corral and turnout area complete this thoughtfully designed setup.

Professionally landscaped grounds frame the home beautifully, enhancing both privacy and presence along one of the Island’s most desirable stretches. From here, you are moments to town, schools, dining, and the golf course, yet elevated above it all in one of Mackinac’s most distinguished residential settings.

Opportunities on West Bluff rarely combine history, condition, views, and functionality at this level. This is not simply a cottage. It is a legacy property, ready for its next chapter.